Photo: The Veendam docked at Costa Maya.I had previously cruised three times on Royal Caribbean during the 1990s. Here’s how this Holland America cruise compared:
Cabins: Our cabin had a flat screen TV, expensive linens, plenty of closet space, a small sofa and room in the bathroom for a bathtub.
Winner: Holland America.Food: On Royal Caribbean, the food had been solid but not exceptional. Sort of like eating at the The Cheesecake Factory every night. On Holland America, the food was all over the place. I was served the most flavorful, tender lamb I’ve ever eaten and I've had some pretty amazing lamb. At another meal, my mother had a roast beef so tough she couldn’t even cut it.
While the ship turned out a chocolate mousse that was a culinary delight in every way, they obviously made their soggy crème brulee without benefit of vanilla beans. (Must have substituted the flan recipe by mistake.) But the most glaring misstep was their fish, which tasted as if it had been under a heat lamp for several hours. We are floating IN the ocean. They ought to get the fish right.
There was no such difficulty with the boiled shrimp, which appeared after our stop in Mexico. It was perfectly cooked and had the just-out-of-the-gulf freshness. Mom and I attempted to eat our weight in them, but having each gained five pounds that week, there wasn't much room left. So really, how picky was I about the food if I gained five pounds? As for overall ratings, I’d rather take the fabulous with the terrible than settle for just plain good. (Which is probably why I choose to live overseas.)
Winner By a Shrimp: Holland America.
Entertainment: Watching the featured entertainers on board was like traveling back in time. The headliner was a guy who did singing impressions. His big impression was Neil Diamond. I’m not sure I would have been that excited to see the REAL Neil Diamond, much less an imitation. This guy's most recent impression was Mick Jagger circa 1960, but he had Jimmy Durante down. Of course, when he did Roger Miller’s “King of the Road,” a popular song 40 years ago, everyone in the audience knew all the words. Not really a Coldplay kind of crowd, I guess.
The comediene hadn’t updated her act in years. “My boyfriend is so young, he’s still playing Pokemon,” she said. Pokemon? This woman talked about Cabbage Patch dolls as if they were still a trend. I know the audience is old, but I'm sure their grandchildren have clued them in on Playstations and Bratz. She did do a hilarious set on getting old. Unfortunately, I got most of those jokes.
The ship had their own small set of singers and dancers who did a couple of shows. I was amused to see them perform “One Night in Bangkok,” a song from the musical Chess. I know it is from Chess because I bought the CD the first and only other time I’d seen that song performed. This happened to be on my last cruise seven years ago. (Apparently, this number comes straight from the cruise entertainment handbook.) On Royal Caribbean, this was performed on a large stage with about 20 dancers and elaborate lights and staging. It just wasn’t the same with six dancers doing their best on a small stage. Royal Caribbean also had Vegas headliners I’d actually heard of.
Winner: Royal Caribbean.Shipboard Activities: Other than Bingo and Trivia Games, Mom and I sampled most of the activities from the ice carving demonstration at poolside to a swing dancing class. (I was taller and got to be the “guy.”) I had gone with mom only because the class had been advertised as line dancing, which I learned in my college disco days.
We had one really fun afternoon of bridge where mom and I trounced the duplicate player who spent the first 15 minutes with her new partner discussing various obscure conventions and transfer bids. (Huh?) But no amount of fancy bidding could save her when she bid 5 clubs over my 4 hearts. (I had 20 high card points and three of her clubs including the ace.) She went down three doubled for 500 points.
I went to one cooking demonstration, where I watched a chef chop celery for 20 minutes. In desperation, the audience started shouting questions to him which he had trouble completely understanding as he wasn’t entirely fluent in English.
We made regular use of the gym and Mom and I even had a spa afternoon. Mom got her hair done, plus also a free lecture from the appalled stylist on how mom’s regular hairdresser had “burned” her hair. Meanwhile, I had a foot and ankle massage followed by a free

machine massage. They put me in this big egg that vibrated and had warm air. It must be what it's like to be a baby, sitting in a carrier on top of running clothes dryer. It was a little hard to relax, as the ship kept blaring announcements and mom was snapping my photo.
But, I must admit, we looked fabulous for our final formal night. Mom, especially, looked spectacular.
We also went to the repeat cruiser “party” where we got a glass of free champagne and watched while they awarded medals to the people who had over 100 days on Holland America. The captain, who looked a little like Richard Gere, awarded a red pin to a 2 year old who had 25 days. He held out his arms for a hug, which the captain gave him.
That toddler was

the only one he touched. In fact, the captain would not shake hands with anyone. After all those people got sick on cruiseships, they are serious about germs here. There were freestanding instant dry liquid soap dispensers EVERYWHERE on ship. And people used them.
I was shocked to learn there were 125 kids on board. I think they must have been shackled below deck as I only ran into about 12 of them all week.
The ship also offered a casino with five cent slot machines where Mom would callously blow $2 at a gambling session. Meanwhile, I went to an "art auction" where the same company was offering prints of some of the same artists, at 10 times the price, of when Larry and I bought on our first cruise ten years ago.
And speaking of shopping, I was astounded to see amber jewelry in the on-board shops at about six times what I pay for it in Russia. My on-board purchase was a half-price sweatshirt to wear while walking the deck at 4 a.m. with jet lag. Mom bought a tee-shirt so she’d have something to wear till her luggage arrived. Otherwise, enamored by how great we looked, we blew all our money on portraits on formal night.
But for activities, Royal Caribbean offered all these plus the occasional lecture and how-to demonstrations.
Winner: Royal Caribbean.
Service: I had about a 10 minute wait to check-in. After that, despite the fact there were 1,200 people on board, I never stood in line for anything. Service in the dining

room was flawless. If I was missing the right utensil, it was silently and instantly replaced. Our cabin was nicely tidied a couple of times day, including fresh towels, and my mom loved the towel creatures our cabin steward left for her entertainment. Of course, the captain HELD the boat for her which is what I call service. You can't really ask for more than that.
Hands down winner: Holland America.Photo: Towel creature assembled by our room steward.